Here’s what the judges said when Crystal closed Rolling Stones night on Idol with “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”

Randy- “Yo–listen–I don’t think it was your BEST performance but let me tell you something, I LOVE YOU! You didn’t dissapoint me!”

Ellen “here’s the thing –you sing with such ease, it’s effortless for you and it’s so much fun to watch you. what’s missing from you is personality and you started adding a little of that tonight…let yourself have fun”

Kara “I agree with Ellen–you’re so comfortable up there but tonight you really realxed and you’re easy to watch”

Simon “The interesting thing is, you came out here tonight 100% the favorite and I think you chose a song that didn’t have what you needed, the drama moment and this is the first time when I think you were beaten by somone and that was Siobhan and that’s why you’ve gotta to always come out with something bigger and better.”

Check back soon for the video from tonight!

Buy Crystal’s Performances on iTunes